By Paul Towers, Pesticide Action Network North America – 14 May 2015
Chalk up another win for the little guy. A handful of residents of Kauai’s Waimea community prevailed in court over biotech giant DuPont-Pioneer last week. Citing extensive, harmful dust generated by DuPont’s seed operations, a jury awarded 15 residents $500,000 in damages.
This is just the latest in an impressive string of victories against pesticide and genetically engineered (GE) seed corporations in Kaua’i, the global epicenter for GE seed testing.
Why the lawsuit? Picture red (pesticide-contaminated) dust blanketing your house and yard, regularly blowing over from neighboring fields, leaving you unable to open your windows or leave your home. That’s what residents of this lower-income community of color have faced for years, and that’s what ended up spurring litigation.
While the judge directed attorneys to focus only on impacts to physical property, it’s hard to ignore the health effects of pesticides drifting through the air or contained in dust blanketing homes. According to court documents, the pesticides sprayed by DuPont in Kaua’i have been linked to cancer, reproductive toxicity, birth defects, disruption of the endocrine, immune & nervous systems, liver damage and more.
Lawyers for the case note that several dozen more Waimea residents may yet come forward to seek awards.
Global profits, local harms
The GE seeds grown in Hawai’i are part of a larger, global story. Corporations based around the globe test and grow GE seeds on the islands before shipping them to places like Iowa to sell to U.S. farmers and across the globe.
DuPont & Co. grow GE seeds year round in Hawai’i, and intensively spray pesticides on these test crops. DuPont-Pioneer is exposing residents in Waimea to 6-8 times the number of pesticides used on the mainland, and in some cases pesticides are applied 15 times more frequently over the course of the year.
Residents on the other side of town are bordered by Syngenta’s operations, including schoolchildren attending Waimea Canyon Middle School. Teachers there have raised concerns about pesticide exposure for years, petitioning federal environmental officials and citing the regular use of brain-harming pesticides.
To address these concerns, residents of Kaua’i helped pass a law in late 2013 to restrict the use of hazardous pesticides near vulnerable communities, and create comprehensive disclosure of pesticide use. The affected multi-national corporations — BASF, Dow, DuPont-Pioneer and Syngenta — promptly sued the County of Kaua’i.
Demanding respect from Syngenta
Earlier this month, a handful of community leaders boarded a plane to Switzerland to share their concerns directly with Syngenta shareholders at their annual meeting. As county councilman Gary Hooser later recounted:
“My message was clear and unambiguous. I asked them to withdraw from their lawsuit against the County of Kaua’i, to honor and follow our laws, and to give our community the same respect and protections afforded to the people in their home country of Switzerland.”
Needless to say, the Kaua’i delegation wasn’t welcomed with open arms by the CEO or company security, but Hooser was able to share a few words directly with shareholders on the big screen, and the small delegation connected with allies in the global movement to advance protections from the use of harmful pesticides.
DuPont, Syngenta and the rest of the Big 6 may have underestimated the power of the Kauaian people, be they neighbors, teachers or elected officials. The corporate giants have awoken the residents, not the other way around.